Is it me or not?

I dont know if its just me or not,
but i seem to get worst training results when using EXTREME even when the players are in high energy. i have monitored for several weeks now and only use extreme on a sunday before the update but the training results drop
has anyone else noticed this?
thanks and all the best

Yep, thats why I use hard even on a Sunday

Before the update? My whole team, including my 5 new youths get extreme'd when they're at full energy

Had the same. I never do extreme its always given me the same if not less apart from the odd freak train on the odd player.

Yes mate, I had the same for 12 months and thought it must be me. I gave up on extreme about 6 months ago and just use hard every day now. My results are no worse.

Wish there was a way to find out because I extreme everyday...

FC Stoke wrote:

Wish there was a way to find out because I extreme everyday...

Firstly how do you manage to keep them alive with daily extreme? And to find out couldn't you train hard for X amount of days, and then train extreme for X amount of days then compare each players' average for the hard days with the extreme days? I know it doesn't consider ups and downs in training score but it should give some sort of comparison?

Yorkshire Knights FC wrote:

FC Stoke wrote:

Wish there was a way to find out because I extreme everyday...

Firstly how do you manage to keep them alive with daily extreme? And to find out couldn't you train hard for X amount of days, and then train extreme for X amount of days then compare each players' average for the hard days with the extreme days? I know it doesn't consider ups and downs in training score but it should give some sort of comparison?

Boosting energy and don't play them in games keeps them above 90% energy daily...

Yeh I have thought about it but as you said how would you know? Dips in training performance and other factors could get in the way of a telling truth...tbh I have never had a problem with extreme...the odd poor performance here n there...but in all honesty I don't know how much of a difference it makes...
All I know is that you remember the poor trains more than the excellent trains...if someone pulled an average of 3 today they would moan about it, but would they praise it when they pulled an average of 6 next week?

FC Stoke wrote:

Yorkshire Knights FC wrote:

FC Stoke wrote:

Wish there was a way to find out because I extreme everyday...

Firstly how do you manage to keep them alive with daily extreme? And to find out couldn't you train hard for X amount of days, and then train extreme for X amount of days then compare each players' average for the hard days with the extreme days? I know it doesn't consider ups and downs in training score but it should give some sort of comparison?

Boosting energy and don't play them in games keeps them above 90% energy daily...

Yeh I have thought about it but as you said how would you know? Dips in training performance and other factors could get in the way of a telling truth...tbh I have never had a problem with extreme...the odd poor performance here n there...but in all honesty I don't know how much of a difference it makes...
All I know is that you remember the poor trains more than the excellent trains...if someone pulled an average of 3 today they would moan about it, but would they praise it when they pulled an average of 6 next week?

Yeah so the only way to get slightly valid data would be to do it over a VERY long period of time. And I uderstand what you're saying about the poor training. I watched a program about mentality not too long ago and it said about how loss effects you more than gain- so if you found 20 pound you would be less happy than you would sad if you lost the 20 pound note. I know it's barely related but I found it interesting haha

thanks for all your replies guys, i think im going to ditch the extreme training