The correct weights for calculating the rating

FC Clock Face wrote:
Checked the keeper figures and they actually DO work out.

So which are right if the ones i posted are correct smiley

Grants Troops wrote:
FC Clock Face wrote:
Checked the keeper figures and they actually DO work out.
So which are right if the ones i posted are correct

I'd go with the new ones to be honest.

Tackling for midfielders seems quite a difference. 15% on the one 3% on the other

Forest Fire wrote:
Tackling for midfielders seems quite a difference. 15% on the one 3% on the other

Edit
This is true but sure have noticed over the past few months midfielders with very low tackling that have higher ratings than the players with the same ability points that have higher tackling over dribbling/finishing etc
I remember STG pointing this out ages ago

FC Dulakubai wrote:
Hi guys. I don't know if you are already aware of these weights or are still stuck with the wrong ones. But I calculated the correct weights for the rating number and here you have them

All percentage of properties are normalized and set up in order of priority.

Keeper:
Handling 19,23%
Aerial 19,23%
Diving 19,23%
One on one 19,23%
Speed 7,69%
Acceleration 7,69%
Passing 1,92%
Stamina 1,92%
Perseverance 1,92%
Leadership 1,92%

Defender:
Tackling 40,54%
Speed 16,89%
Acceleration 16,89%
Passing 6,76%
Dribbling 3,38%
Stamina 3,38%
Perseverance 3,38%
Leadership 3,38%
Set pieces 3,38%
Finishing 2,03%

Midfielder:
Passing 22,58%
Dribbling 19,35%
Stamina 16,13%
Finishing 12,90%
Speed 9,68%
Perseverance 6,45%
Tackling 3,23%
Acceleration 3,23%
Set pieces 3,23%
Leadership 3,23%

Forward:
Finishing 30,03%
Dribbling 24,02%
Speed 15,02%
Acceleration 15,02%
Passing 3%
Perseverance 3%
Leadership 3%
Set pieces 3%
Stamina 2,4%
Tackling 1,5%

Are these more correct than the once Grants Troops is referring too?(have always been using that one)
I would love to know, which one is the correct weight.

i think the tackling may differ looking at my mids compared to others on the market. I reckon they have a similar weighting to dribbling

Grants Troops wrote:
So these are wrong?

Keepers

Handling 25%
Aerial 25%
One on one 12%
Diving 11%
Stamina 7%
Speed 6%
Acceleration 5%
Passing 3%
Leadership 3%
Perseverance 3%

Defenders

Tackling 35%
Stamina 18%
Speed 13%
Acceleration 13%
Passing 6%
Dribbling 3%
Leadership 3%
Perseverance 3%
Finishing 3%
Set pieces 3%

Midfielders

Passing 20%
Stamina 15%
Tackling 15%
Speed 10%
Acceleration 10%
Dribbling 10%
Finishing 8%
Set pieces 6%
Leadership 3%
Perseverance 3%

Forwards

Finishing 34%
Dribbling 20%
Speed 14%
Acceleration 14%
Passing 3%
Stamina 3%
Tackling 3%
Leadership 3%
Perseverance 3%
Set pieces 3%

These weights are wrong. Danmark estimated those. Fx. he overvalues Tackling for Midfielders and Stamina for Defenders.

I calculated the weights directly from the code. My weights are right. Please pass it on so we can correct the mistake and make a level playing field smiley

Thanks, nice to know smiley

FC Dulakubai wrote:
These weights are wrong. Danmark estimated those. Fx. he overvalues Tackling for Midfielders and Stamina for Defenders.

I calculated the weights directly from the code. My weights are right. Please pass it on so we can correct the mistake and make a level playing field

Thanks. This is a great post, surprised it didn't get more discussion before being bumped.

I still don't understand why tackling only weights 3.23% for midfielders. "The ability to take the ball from an opponent" should be considered as a core ability for a midfielder, especially defensive midfielders.
I mean if we compare two players who are pretty much at the same stage:

One of them being mine the other one yours:
Amjad Shareef
Link removed, player on transfer list - Daz

I've always focused tackling on midfielders, which has given a good rating and comparing those two players then it doesn't really tell which method is the correct/best one.

Anyways, i'll be using your calculation from now on since getting a high rating on midfielders have always been so difficult in the early stage compared to other positions.

So thanks smiley

Forums

Miscellaneous